Vietnam: No Country for #MeToo
Government connections protect those
implicated in sexual violence.
By
Elaine Pearson, Asia Director
Published in: The
Diplomat
January 24, 2025
In November, during Vietnamese
President Luong Cuong’s visit to
Chile, a member of his security detail, Lai Dac Tuan, was arrested on accusations
of sexual assault. A
Chilean judge ordered him to leave
the country and prohibited him from returning for two years. Lai is a lieutenant
colonel in Vietnam’s Ministry of Public Security, which is known for its ruthless
suppression of dissent. While Chilean
and foreign media covered
the story, no word of it appeared in the government-controlled Vietnamese media.
Last March, two restaurant servers in New Zealand accused two Vietnamese
policemen of indecent assault when they were in the country to
prepare for Prime Minister Pham Minh
Chinh’s official
visit. The accused fled New Zealand
before they could be arrested. In December, following questions from the media
about the case, New Zealand police confirmed they “have no doubt these two women
were indecently assaulted by two men while working, and had these men still been
in New Zealand we would have pursued criminal charges.” Vietnamese domestic
media were silent about this incident too.
Violence against women and girls, including sexual violence, is pervasive in
Vietnam, and victims rarely feel able to seek help. These are just two
incidents, notable because they occurred in foreign countries where victims came
forward to the police and media reported the allegations. Inside Vietnam, sexual
assault cases are rarely reported to authorities because of stigma, victim
blaming, and a culture of impunity in which perpetrators who are well-connected
to the government are rarely held to account.
In February 2022, Forbes Vietnam published its “2022 Under 30” list; among those
featured was Ngo
Hoang Anh, a leading member of the
Ministry of Health’s COVID-19 information technology team. After a number of
women came forward to
accuse him of sexual harassment,
Forbes announced that
it had removed Ngo from its list. But there is no indication of any legal action
being taken against him.
In March 2022, in a rare case reported to the authorities, a woman referred to
publicly as V. N. H. reported
to the police that Le Minh Tien,
chair of the Department of International Law at Hanoi Law University, had
sexually assaulted her multiple times between 2020 and 2022. Hanoi Law is a
public university under the direct supervision of the Ministry of Justice. In
July 2022, the Ministry of Justice said that the case was under
police investigation, and in
April 2023, Justice officials said
that Le had been given a “warning”
and had left his position. There was no further published information about the
investigation.
In April 2022, the poet Da Thao Phuong alleged that
she had been raped and assaulted in 1999-2000 by a co-worker, Luong Ngoc An,
when the two were working at Van Nghe Tre (Young Literature and Arts), a
subsidiary of the state-owned Van Nghe (Literature and Arts) newspaper.
At the time that Da made her case public, Luong was a senior Communist Party
member of the Executive Committee of the official Vietnam Writers Association,
and also deputy editor-in-chief of Van Nghe. Da also accused the
late Truong Vinh Tuan – the deputy editor-in-chief of Van Nghe in 2000s
who was assigned to deal with her allegation – of preventing her from filing a
complaint, and retaliating by slandering her, refusing to publish her work, and
threatening to fire her.
Ten days after Da published allegations on social media in April 2022, another
poet, Bui
Mai Hanh, alleged that Luong Ngoc An
had also sexually assaulted her. Several days later, the Vietnam Writers
Association announced that as of May 1, 2022, Luong would no
longer be the deputy editor-in-chief of Van
Nghe. The association did not
provide a reason.
In December 2024, after two and a half years in hiatus, Luong was promoted to deputy
editor-in-chief of another
state-controlled magazine – an appointment that caused a renewed
uproar on social media. On January 4,
2025, the Vietnam Writers Association abruptly announced that it had withdrawn “its
decision regarding the appointment of Luong Ngoc An,” again without any
explanation.
These cases share a common theme: the accused are either state employees or
closely affiliated with state institutions, and often Vietnamese Communist Party
members. Despite the severity of the accusations, there have been no criminal
investigations of the suspects, no prosecutions, and virtually no punishments.
The state’s response has been complete silence or worse. And these cases are
just the ones publicly reported.
Much of the research on violence against women in Vietnam has focused on
intimate partner violence. According to U.N.
Women, in Vietnam “nearly 2 in every
3 women… have experienced one or more forms of physical, sexual, emotional and
economic violence as well as controlling behavior by a husband/partner in their
life. More than 90 percent of women who experienced sexual and/or physical
violence by their husband/partner did not seek any help from formal services or
authorities.”
In a 2016 report,
ActionAid found that “87 percent of Vietnamese women and girls have encountered
sexual harassment in a public place,” and “89 percent of men and bystanders have
witnessed acts of sexual harassment against women and girls.” The anthropologist
Nguyen Thu Huong has
argued that sexual assault cases
persist because Vietnam’s inadequate legal system, combined with social stigma
and a “victim blaming” culture, discourages victims of sexual assaults from
coming forward and seeking justice.
In responding to a recent United
Nations review of its human rights
record, Vietnam accepted all recommendations to promote gender equality and to
combat gender violence, including sexual violence against women. If the
government is serious about upholding its pledges, then the first step would be
for the Vietnamese authorities to carry out thorough and transparent
investigations into all reports of sexual violence against women, and fully and
impartially prosecute those responsible, regardless of their political status or
connections.